This page contains reviews of films seen during the months of January to March 2012 | ||
“The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo”-This is the third version of this story that I have experienced. The first was Stieg Larsson’s book. The second was the Swedish movie of the same name, reviewed in 2010. And now this version. And although it is a decent film, it’s also a film that did not need to be made as the Swedish version was just fine and told the story in a simpler and more succinct manner. The story is summarized in my previous review and so I’ll concentrate on the performances and other production values. Being familiar with the story, I can say that this film does a fairly good job of setting forth the dramatic thriller elements of a tale about a seemingly disgraced writer, Mikael Blomkvist (Daniel Craig), chosen to explore the family mystery of an extremely wealthy Swedish family, the Vangers, who live in Hedestad several hundred miles north of Stockholm; and the life and ultimate involvement in the mystery of Lisbeth Salander (Rooney Mara), one of the most unusual characters to be seen in a long time. Knowing the story fairly well, I tried to imagine how it would appear to someone who was not at all familiar with the tale and I found that it was likely to be pretty confusing at the start. The film jumps back and forth between Blomkvist and Salander until the stories finally merge. Some of the dialogue is hard to follow which is funny since it’s in English. I found it a little annoying to hear actors trying to portray Swedes by adding slight accents which was made even sillier by the fact that some didn’t try at all. Had not Noomi Rapace already done Lisbeth Salander to perfection, I would be more impressed with Rooney Mara’s stunning take on Lisbeth Salander, an extremely eccentric computer expert. Salander is a ward of the state, and the reasons for that are an important element in this story and the two “Girl” tales to follow, and when her first and decent guardian suffers a stroke, he is replaced by Nils Bjurman (Yorick van Wageningen), a pervert who will be very sorry that he chose to cross Salander. Ultimately, “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo” has too many stories to tell. The primary theme about the Vanger family mystery (the disappearance 40 years earlier of teenage Harriet Vanger) is at the heart of the film but is wrapped up far too quickly and abandoned (and with a somewhat different ending than contained in the book and the first film) so that the filmmakers could move on to show how Lisbeth manipulates Wennerstrom, the man who disgraced Blomkvist, out of his money and his life. Unfortunately, at the end of this rather long film (158 minutes), I was somewhat relieved that it was over. B (3/22/12) | |